The first time I was back at C’s after her mopey episode, I was in the kitchen making chicken sandwiches and I asked if the ladies wanted mayo. C, ever ladylike, hollered back, “You know I love your ‘MAN-aise’ all over my breasts, baby.” (chicken breast, get it?) V jokingly lamented that C was hogging all the “man-aise”, and C said “maybe if you get on your knees and ask nicely you can get some man-aise on your breast too. You might have to help shake the container though.” “Don’t worry,” I hollered back, “I’ve got plenty here for both of you,” which led to riotous giggling that subsided as I brought the plates into the living room.
C announced that she was afraid to taste the sandwich now, and V said, “I don’t even care, I’m starved,” ate a bite and declared, “honey, your boyfriend’s MAN-aise is delicious,” cracking herself up to the point of choking on the bite she was chewing. “Don’t choke,” I told her. Recovering she said, “I know, that’s C’s job.” C perked up at that and said, “Wait a minute, how come you act all concerned and tell V not to choke, and with me you’re shoving it in and telling me to choke on it?” “Because that’s how you like it,” I retorted, to which she replied “Oh yeah, ok.” “Dayam,” V said, fanning herself, “this is the hottest conversation about a chicken sandwich ever.”
“Oh,” C said, “I thought we were talking about his cock and what comes out,” and cackled.
V made a frowny face and said, “Oh sure it’s funny for you when you two get to go in your room and lock the door later. I’m the one who’s going to be scrounging batteries out of the remote.” C said “awwwww” and then ordered V to report to her for snuggles, then enlisted me to make it a group snuggle. We’ve engaged in “hug sandwiches” with C in the middle before, but this was the first time we’d done it with V in the middle. “This is nice,” V said,and then told me, “Poor guy, you can be in the middle next time.” C said,Nah, he won’t make good sandwich meat, no boobies!” and squeezed V’s right breast.
C and V do this kind of “innocent” grabbing of boobs and butts as they pass each other in the hall or kitchen or whatever, as well as caressing hugs and closed-lip kisses at bedtime and the like. When we’ve snuggled with C in the middle before, there have been little contests between V and I where one of us gives C a peck and the other follows suit pointedly, usually culminating in a breast squeeze by one of us that the other imitates. V sarcastically stated, “When C’s in the middle, her left boob doesn’t get left hanging,” so I cupped her left breast and gave her and C both a “so there” eyebrow.
C looked at me with challenge in her eyes as she leaned down to kiss V’s cheek, so I did the same. She raised an eyebrow at me and leaned forward to give V a peck on the lips, which I also began to imitate, but V got weirded out and extricated herself. C pouted and promised to behave if V returned to the couch, but V said she was going to go to her room to read and leave us to be alone. Then she said “Whew, where’s that remote anyway?”
C and I canoodled a bit more before retiring to her bedroom. Post-coitus she reminisced about how flustered we’d gotten V, giggling, then asked how far I would have taken it. I told her I was the one following her lead, but I wouldn’t have backed down from a challenge. She asked if I thought us playing that game with V was mean, and I said I doubted it, and that the “joke” about finding the remote was Vs way of letting us know that she did enjoy it, and that she was really going to masturbate about what had transpired, even though it had gotten too real too fast just then. I warned her not to be surprised if V became a little distant or skittish about the affection stuff for a while.
C asked if I had found it fun. And I replied that she knew I enjoyed pushing her boundaries, and that yes it was definitely fun pushing both hers and by extension V’s. She asked if I was disappointed that it didn’t go further and I told her that no, mostly, because getting V to the point of blushing and needing a break was the fun part, but that it seemed to me that C was ready to go a little further yet, and so I was disappointed that I didn’t get to see how far she was willing to go before getting shy. I asked if she was disappointed, and she said no because it was fun and all, but she didn’t want to do anything V would regret, and didn’t know if she was ready to see me doing “certain things” with V just yet, even though she was pushing because she was curious to see if I would.
I warned her that if she made it a challenge as she had, I would go as far as she pushed and V was willing. She said she wondered if we were taking advantage of V being lonely and horny because after all V is straight. I told her I didn’t know, but that in my observation, there are certainly straighter girls than V, but that if she felt like continuing to pursue this course, we should make sure it was always when sober to be extra sure no advantage is being taken.
C laughed and said, “And here I was thinking about how we should have drinks after dinner tonight to loosen up.”
I told her not to be in a hurry, that I knew she’d gotten a thrill out of that day’s events, but wouldn’t it, after all, be more fun to spread that thrill out and take out time getting to whatever level it finally got to? She conceded that, but said that she was more thinking about how she didn’t like V being lonely and having to masturbate when she had two people who loved her and could be “taking care of that”. “You love V, don’t you?” she asked, “I mean not like me, but as a friend right?” She talked about how the felt V was her family and that it would be nice if we could all just be one family together. I asked if this was all about creating something she wanted or about preventing something she didn’t want. She was confused, rightly so, and I explained that I wondered if this might not be more about being afraid of losing V to some guy that might come along than about wanting to share me with V and V with me.
She said, “the other day when you were alone with her I tried to imagine how I would feel if you were fucking, and it made me sad, but then I thought about if it was some other dude she was with and I don’t know which bothered me more.” “I know,” she said, “I’m just selfish because I don’t want to lose either of you guys.”
She seemed frustrated about her feelings getting in the way of the “logic” of making this a triad. I told her it didn’t make any sense to sacrifice her needs to have me to herself to try and hang onto V, because I knew that no matter what, she wouldn’t lose V to any guy who did come along. “I know,” she moped, “but also I think about how who knows who she might date and they might be a jerk or not even good in bed and I know you aren’t a jerk, and that you’re definitely good in bed.”
I told her that it didn’t sound like a good idea to me, to become involved sexually/romantically with V together out of fear of unknowns. Her rebuttal was that it didn’t seem like a good reason to avoid it either. “True,” I said, “so you should put some thought into figuring out what you want, rather than what you don’t.” “And,” I added, “keep in mind that V gets to choose what she wants, too.” “I know,” she replied.
Later that evening, at bedtime, she and V did their traditional hug and kiss while I stood by. Afterward, V looked at me and said, “Well?” so I hugged her and gave her a soft peck on the cheek. “On the lips, buster,” she chided. “Yeah,” C agreed, so I did. “I love you guys,” V told us. “We love you too,” we replied.
When we got to her room, C said, “That was so cute. I almost want to tell you to go spend the night with V. You guys were adorable.”
“Oh?” I asked. “Yes,” C responded, “except I need you to fuck the shit out of me right now, so no.”
We haven’t all been at their house at the same time really since then, so not much else has happened.The night before last, C and V slept together. “Slept!” C emphasized, and said it was mainly for the purpose of warmth. There has apparently been a brief conversation about what happened the other day, in which V admitted to having fun but getting weirded out at the same time, with some discussion about what a “good guy” I am for not immediately trying to push for a threesome at the slightest hint. C has been extra clingy after that day though.